The Ultimate Throw Pillow Guide For Your Home Refresh

Last week I opened my pillow cover closet for my daughter-in-law and told her to take a couple home. I realized how much pillow advice I was passing along with the covers. Which insert to buy. How to size it. How to work the insert into the cover without breaking the invisible zipper.

That afternoon convinced me to gather everything (from SEVERAL pillow posts over the years) into one place. It’s true, I love designer pillows. I’m discerning and will spend more on them sometimes than on shoes.

After decades of decorating for clients and refreshing my own rooms, I can tell you that nothing changes a space faster or for less money than new pillows. Same sofa, same rug, same art, entirely new room.

The Ultimate Throw Pillow Guide

So this is my complete pillow guide: how to size them, how to mix them, how many to use, how to get them stuffed and looking plump, and where I buy them. Bookmark it, pin it, and come back whenever a room needs a lift.

There are some affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Thanks for your support.

Start With the Insert

The most common pillow mistake has nothing to do with fabric. It’s a limp, undersized insert.

Buy inserts 2 inches larger than the cover. For a 22 inch square cover, order a 24 inch insert. This gives you that plump, designer look instead of sad, floppy corners. I order mine here.

Choose feather and down (like a 95/5 or 90/10 feather to down combination), a synthetic feather blend, or a good down alternative if you have allergies. Skip stiff foam and flat poly-fil.

One more note on sizing: a cover’s flat dimension changes once it’s stuffed. A 20 x 20 cover gains depth and loses a little height and width when filled. Retail pillow inserts often run small, so size up at stores like Pottery Barn. They will let you try them out in the store.

How to Stuff a Cover Without Breaking the Zipper

This is the tip I found myself demonstrating for my daughter-in-law, because a broken invisible zipper ruins a beautiful cover. That oversized insert has to go in gently.

1. Unzip the cover completely, all the way to the end. Forcing an insert through a half-open zipper is how the pull comes off the track.
2. Fold the insert in half like a taco and slide it in folded.
3. Let it unfold inside, then work each corner of the insert into each corner of the cover. Reach in and push the feathers where you want them.
4. Zip slowly while holding the fabric taut just ahead of the pull, so the fabric doesn’t catch in the teeth.
5. Finish with a fluff and a light karate chop if that’s your look.

What Size Pillows for Your Sofa, Chairs and Bed

These are not rules, just foolproof guidelines for arrangements that look balanced and feel comfortable.

• Standard sofas: 22 inch square is the designer rule of thumb. Larger pillows (22 to 24 inch) read more luxe than small ones.
• Low-back or mid-century seating: 22 inch squares work, or try a 20 x 20 or 12 x 22 lumbar if you prefer a lower profile or if the seat is shorter like in a banquet.
• Chairs: One 20 or 22 inch square, or a small lumbar.
• Sectionals: Same a sofas, except you may want a 24″ in the corner where it’s deeper
• Beds: Larger scale is your friend. Euro shams (26 inch) against the headboard, then squares, then a lumbar in front.

My Pattern Mixing Formula

Think about the patterns you gravitate to in your own closet. Stripes, florals, geometrics, solids? Texture counts as a pattern too. Then use this formula:

One large scale pattern + one medium or small pattern + one solid or textured solid.

That’s it. The large pattern leads, the smaller pattern supports, and the solid (velvet, woven cotton, linen, faux fur) ties it together.

For color:

1. If you prefer a subtle, modern look, keep it monochromatic. Neutrals never go out of style. If the room already has bold pattern in the rug, art or the view out the window, matching solid pillows can be the right call.
2. If you enjoy color, pick one main color and one or two complementary colors. Let your artwork, rug or surroundings inspire the palette.

How Many Pillows and How to Arrange Them

• Odd numbers are pleasing. Three pillows on a smaller sofa, or four squares plus one lumbar on a standard sofa.
• On a large sectional, three in the center and two at each end.
• For easy balance, place two matching solid pillows at opposite ends of the sofa.
• Put larger pillows at the ends with smaller ones layered in front.
• A draped throw blanket adds comfort and visual interest, especially with an even number of pillows. It can do the work of a pillow from a color and texture standpoint. Quince makes luxurious solid cashmere throws at a reasonable price.

Where I Buy Pillows: My Favorite Sources

These are the sources I return to again and again. Etsy shops using designer fabric doing and seven retail destinations covering a range of styles and budgets. Some are not affiliates. I just think you should know about them.

Etsy Shops

Etsy is still one of the best places to find pillow makers working in small batches, often with designer fabrics and custom options.

• Krinto. Global textile traditions with a faded, collected color palette. Handmade in California with invisible zippers. Beautiful with linen, rattan and layered interiors.
• Pillow Fever. A wide range of stripes, geometrics and prints, and the quality holds up for the price. This is where I send friends who want to try a new color without a big commitment.
• Flying Tack. The shop for anyone ready to commit to color. At home in a library, reading room or any traditional-to-transitional space.
• Pop O’ Color: Bold Color · Playful · Statement Pieces
• Spark Modern Contemporary · Graphic · Design-Forward
  is for interiors that lean contemporary. The designs are graphic — geometric patterns, clean lines, color used with purpose. Great quality.

Retailers

• Walter G. An Australian textile brand working with artisan weavers and block printers in India. Depth of color, a handmade quality, and the fabrics coordinate well together.
• Pottery Barn. Consistency. Broad range, reliable quality, and my favorite place for solid Belgian linen covers in 19 colors.
• Wayfair. Not the first name that comes to mind for design shopping, but the range is hard to beat. I use the filters (color, pattern, size, material) like a search engine when I know what I’m looking for.
• McGee & Co. Studio McGee · Transitional · Elevated Casual
• CB2: Modern · Graphic · Contemporary Edge
• Crate & Barrel is also a good place to look. The blue velvet stitched lumbars are from Crate & Barrel.
• Bastideaux French-Inspired · Provençal · Boutique
  
  Linen and Cloth Natural Fibers · Organic · Artisan-Made
  Linen and Cloth is rooted in natural fibers and undyed textures. They serve as the quiet neutral in a layered arrangement, and they suit any interior that values the organic and the handmade.

Caring for and Storing Your Pillows

Buy covers, not finished pillows, whenever you can. Store the covers flat in a closet and reuse the same good inserts every time you want a new look. This is how a pillow habit stays affordable. And as my daughter-in-law can now attest, a well-kept stash means you always have something to share.

Dry clean or gently hand wash covers and air dry. Don’t throw them in the machine, and don’t let the dog claim them. Fluff back cushions and flip seat cushions while you’re at it.

I swap covers seasonally: linen and cotton for spring and summer, velvet and heavier textures for fall and winter. Same inserts, same sofa, completely different mood.

The Bottom Line

Pick one room. Decide what it needs: more color, more texture, or more calm. Then mix your scales, mix your textures, don’t fear an odd number, and always size up the insert. Zip gently.

If you found this guide helpful, pin it for later and share it with a fellow pillow addict.

Shop The Post:

You may also like My Sister’s Living Room Winter Pillow Swap.